Environmental, Social & Governance applied to corporates against commercial credit risks

by | May 20, 2022 | ESG

Over the past five years discussion around the role of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) in credit risk has become a sticking point with qualitative considerations and forecasts becoming material in risk analysis. A report by Macquarie Group has shown that securities with low ESG scores generally show greater volatility returns than securities with high ESG scores. The United Nations Principles of Responsible Investment (UN PRI) have a signatory list for ESG in Credit Ratings Statement now supported by over 130 investors (US $26trn in AUM) and by 16 credit rating agencies[1]

As Macquarie mention, securities with a low ESG score averaged a standard deviation score of 32.4, whilst securities with a high ESG score averaged a 26.9. This difference is most notable with BBB rated securities, with a +15.5 difference in standard deviation score between the highest and lowest ESG scores. Based on these differences, ESG scores of securities can be a tool of assistance when determining potential return volatility, and a flag for further investigation from credit analysts.[2]

The Macquarie Group also states the governance aspect of ESG ratings in securities to have already been properly priced, and that no alpha returns remain to be extracted. This is because governance has traditionally been a factor of assessment in credit risk analysis. Outside of governance, the benefits of delving into company’s environmental and social information (other than those used in public scores) will deliver better returns for investors whilst also strengthening their portfolio with ESG characteristics.

Variable factors will also play a role in measuring the effect of social and governance levels of risk, such as an entity’s sector, geographical location and characteristics of the instrument. S&P mention in the two year period from 2015 to 2017 there were more than 1000 corporate ratings for which an environmental or social factor was an important element in their rating analysis.[3]

The key factors investors are looking to see ESG addressed by corporates and projects consist of:

  • Incorporate ESG factors into investment analysis & decision making processes;

  • Seek appropriate disclosure and transparency on ESG issues;

  • Reporting on activities and progress towards implementing ESG risk management processes.

As sustainability reporting becomes an essential requirement for businesses to attract investors over time, technology and availability of data will become more accessible to businesses of all sizes and market capitalisations. New models for ratings will also begin to mature, and quantitative ESG ratings will shift from avoiding risk to capturing opportunity. Due to the long-term nature of ESG risks, combining ESG information with a fundamental analysis particularly compliments buy-and-hold strategies, with their concerns about bond liquidity and issuers’ strategic and business risks.

[1] https://www.unpri.org/credit-ratings/statement-on-esg-in-credit-ratings/77.article

[2] https://static.macquarie.com/dafiles/Internet/mgl/global/shared/sf/images/corporate/asset-management/investment-management/understanding-esg-in-credit-portfolios.pdf?v=3

[3] https://www.spratings.com/en_US/products/-/product-detail/our-approach-to-esg-in-rating

Contact us to discuss how your organisation can reduce ESG risks, create an effective ESG strategy, reduce their carbon footprint and better manage ESG risk in your supply chain.

Recent Posts

Introducing ESG Today

by | Dec 2, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

Introducing the flagship television show, ESG Today, in collaboration with Import Export TV! The interactive Environmental, Social and Governance show, with the very...

Business culture

Creating A Positive Workplace Culture

by | Dec 1, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

Globalisation in its wake has ensured that each individual has several job opportunities to choose from. It entails every individual striving to get a job that enables...


About the ESGRI Academy

by | Jun 21, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

ESGRI’s platform provides a wealth of opportunities for employees to learn new skills, advance their careers and instill a strong sense of ESG throughout an...


Real-Time Supply Chain ESG management

by | Jun 21, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

“Two-thirds of the average company’s environment, social, and governance footprint lies with suppliers. Procurement leaders who take bold action can make a decisive...


Pricing Benefits to both issuers and investors for Green Bonds | Climate Bonds Initiative

by | May 20, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

The Climate Bonds Initiative recently released the latest Green Bond Pricing report, with an assessment of the performance of issuances in the second half of 2021. The...


ESG Impact announces partnership with Ethical Trade Alliance

by | May 20, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

Media Release – March 2, 2022 ESG Impact (ESGI) is pleased to announce its partnership with Ethical Trade Alliance (ETA). As an alliance partner of the ETA, ESGRI’s...

Australian ESG News – Q3 2021

by | May 20, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

Greenpeace Australia Pacific launches Hero to zero: uncovering the truth of corporate Australia's climate action claims, reviewing the targets of 80 of the highest...

Global ESG News – Q3 2021

by | May 20, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

The Biden Plan for a clean energy revolution and environmental proposal will make a federal investment of $1.7 trillion over the next ten years, leveraging additional...

Environmental, Social & Governance (ESG) Supply Chain Risk Management

by | May 20, 2022 | ESG | 0 Comments

Modern day supply chains are complex, changing, and fraught with risk management challenges. One scary statistic we hear these days is that over the past 2 two years...